This article is a contribution from the accounting firm Milestone. If you would like to share quality content for startups in the form of a contribution, please contact the Venture Square editorial team at editor@venturesquare.net.
Goodwill valuation and tax treatment for individuals and corporations upon conversion to a corporation
When a sole proprietorship converts to a corporation, the valuation of goodwill must be reviewed. Goodwill can lead to additional tax burdens, such as gift tax, depending on the transaction structure, so thorough pre-evaluation is necessary. Therefore, this article will focus on the method of evaluating goodwill during corporate conversion and the tax treatment for both the sole proprietorship and the transferee corporation.
1. Basic principles
The conversion of a sole proprietorship to a corporation constitutes a transaction between related parties under tax law, and therefore must be conducted at market value. If the sole proprietor (representative) transfers goodwill to the corporation during this process, the proceeds from the goodwill are taxed as miscellaneous income under the Income Tax Act. Meanwhile, in cases where relatives, etc. participate as shareholders after the corporation's incorporation, the transfer of goodwill without separate consideration may be considered a gratuitous transfer of goodwill to the shareholders, subject to gift tax. In fact, the National Tax Service has previously ruled that a case where a sole proprietor transferred assets without separately assessing or paying for the goodwill upon conversion to a corporation, and then a relative later joined as a shareholder, effectively resulted in a gratuitous transfer of goodwill, thus qualifying as a gift.
2. Method of evaluating the market value of goodwill
If there is an appraised value for goodwill, the market value is applied based on that appraised value. If there is no appraised value, the value of goodwill is calculated according to the valuation method stipulated in the Inheritance Tax and Gift Tax Act.
3. Tax treatment related to goodwill
(1) Individual business owner (representative)
Income from the transfer of goodwill is classified as miscellaneous income under the Income Tax Act. 60% of the transfer price is recognized as necessary expenses, and only 40% is taxed. The attribution date for miscellaneous income is determined by the earliest of the payment settlement date, the date of commencement of use/profit, or the date of delivery. Even if the goodwill is not actually paid in the year of incorporation, individual business owners are still required to file and pay comprehensive income tax on it, assuming that other income accrued in that year. Furthermore, when a corporation pays the goodwill, it is subject to withholding tax at 8.8% of the payment. However, if the payment is made after the representative has already filed and paid the comprehensive income tax, withholding tax is not applied, but the obligation to submit a payment statement still exists.
(2) Transferee corporation
The corporation records the amount of goodwill paid as an intangible asset and amortizes it over a period of five years.
4. Things to note when converting to a corporation
When goodwill arises, it is necessary to check whether other income is reported and withholding tax is paid.
Furthermore, when converting to a corporation through a comprehensive acquisition, not only tax and accounting issues but also various permits and administrative procedures must be reviewed. For example, mail-order businesses require a title transfer process, and the required documentation and processing time vary depending on the platform, so verification is essential. Furthermore, verifying whether and how long loans from individual business owners will be transferred, as well as the transfer process and deadlines for subsidies from individual business owners, are also important considerations.
Meanwhile, when converting to a corporation during a fiscal year, it's important to consider how tax credits and exemptions are applied. The tax reduction for startup SMEs applies to both individual and corporate business owners for the tax year in question. However, the employment enhancement tax credit only applies to corporate business owners, not individual business owners.
Incorporation is a transaction that organically involves not only tax and accounting matters, but also related administrative procedures . Therefore, prior review of goodwill valuation and taxation issues is essential for a successful incorporation. A comprehensive review of the transferability of various rights and obligations, including scheduling, is crucial .
- See more related columns
You must be logged in to post a comment.